Top Customer Support Outsourcing Companies
-
Featured
What are Featured Providers?
$1,000+< $25 / hr1,000 - 9,999Chicago, ILServices provided
See all 28 projectsHugo Inc. | Top CX Provider is a leading Customer Support Outsourcing firm, offering services such as Call Center Outsourcing and Customer Service BPO. The company is highly praised for its efficient project management and adaptability, with 100% of reviewers appreciating their seamless communication and integration into business processes. Their capacity to scale and maintain high service quality is consistently highlighted, contributing to improved customer satisfaction and operational efficiency.
$5,000+< $25 / hr1,000 - 9,999Lexington, KYServices provided
See all 46 projectsHelpware is a Customer Service Outsourcing company that specializes in delivering remote customer care solutions, including troubleshooting, multi-lingual support, and 24/7 service capabilities. Reviews indicate a strong emphasis on professionalism, adaptability, and relationship building, with 100% positive feedback highlighting their excellent client interaction and reliable project management. Clients commend Helpware’s ability to meet quotas and deadlines consistently.
UndisclosedUndisclosed1,000 - 9,999Limassol, CyprusServices provided
See all 37 projectsMindy Support is a Customer Service BPO specializing in multilingual customer support, call center outsourcing, and remote customer care services. Reviews indicate a 100% satisfaction rate, with clients praising their efficient project management and proactive communication. Notable strengths include scalability and timely delivery, though there is a suggestion to expand language offerings and enhance training for telephone support staff.
-
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Brisbane, CA
Services provided
VOX Network Solutions is a software development firm. The team focuses on Custom Software Development and Customer Service Outsourcing and is located in Brisbane, California.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Antananarivo, Madagascar
Services provided
See all 1 projectsWe.CARe offers Customer Support Outsourcing (CSO) services, specializing in reliable problem resolution for telecommunications companies. Reviews highlight their impressive customer care and effective communication, leading to high satisfaction and positive feedback from end customers. The company's affordability and proximity are also noted as significant advantages.
-
Featured
What are Featured Providers?
$1,000+Undisclosed250 - 999Brooklyn, NYServices provided
See all 67 projectsTop Customer Service is a prominent provider of Customer Support Outsourcing and Call Center Solutions, offering services such as inbound call handling and customer inquiry management. With a 100% satisfaction rate, clients commend their professionalism and efficiency, noting significant improvements in response times and client satisfaction. Approximately 75% of reviewers praise their seamless integration and alignment with company values.
-
$1,000+< $25 / hr50 - 249
Services provided
NextCall, a call center service, was established in 2015. The firm specializes in Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing.
Read more -
$1,000+< $25 / hr50 - 249Scottsdale, AZ
Services provided
Liveops, a call center company, was founded in 2000. The team offers Call Center Services and Sales Outsourcing.
Read more -
$1,000+< $25 / hr50 - 249Pleasant Hill, CA
Services provided
Call24 Communications, an answering service, is located in Pleasant Hill, California. Founded in 1985, the team focuses on Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing.
Read more -
$1,000+< $25 / hr50 - 249Los Angeles, CA
Services provided
Business Consulting company SD&A Teleservices is based in Los Angeles, California. Their services include Business Consulting and Call Center Services.
Read more -
$1,000+< $25 / hr50 - 249Los Angeles, CA
Services provided
CallCentersNow, a call center, was established in 2015. They focuses on Call Center Services and Sales Outsourcing.
Read more -
$1,000+$25 - $49 / hr50 - 249Lake Elmo, MN
Services provided
Greetings, Neighbor! is an answering service company. They are based in Lake Elmo, Minnesota and have midsize team. Their team specializes in Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing.
Read more -
$25,000+$25 - $49 / hr50 - 249San Diego, CA
Services provided
Phone Ware is a telephone answering service based in San Diego, California. Launched in 1977, the team provides Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing.
Read more -
$1,000+< $25 / hr50 - 249Oslo, Norway
Services provided
ProffCom AS, a midsize call center, is based in Oslo, Norway. Their services include Call Center Services and Sales Outsourcing.
Read more -
$1,000+< $25 / hr50 - 249Köln, Germany
Services provided
Office Call-Center GmbH is a telephone answering service. They were founded in 1998 and focus on Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Katowice, Poland
Services provided
4EN, a call center, offer Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing. They were founded in 2002.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Niles, IL
Services provided
Midsize call center service Around The Clock Answering Service, is located in Niles, Illinois. The team offers Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249ঢাকা, Bangladesh
Services provided
NIMBUS TEK is an answering service. The ঢাকা, Bangladesh-based team focuses on Call Center Services and Back Office Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249St. John's, Canada
Services provided
Launched in 2003, Talon Energy Services is an Engineering company. The firm specializes in Engineering and Customer Service Outsourcing, and is midsize.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Columbus, OH
Services provided
Fortuity is an answering service. Headquartered in Columbus, Ohio, their midsize team offers Call Center Services and Back Office Outsourcing. The firm was established in 2017.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Ashwaubenon, WI
Services provided
Launched in 1972, Anser Services is a call center service. The agency focuses on Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing, and is midsize.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Troy, MI
Services provided
SunTel Services is a telephone answering service. In Troy, Michigan, the team specializes in Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Berlin, VT
Services provided
Established in 1993, All Ways Answering is a midsize answering service company. Their services include Call Center Services and Back Office Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Zabrze, Poland
Services provided
S8 SA, a telephone answering service, was founded in 2014. The company specializes in Call Center Services and Back Office Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Warszawa, Poland
Services provided
Midsize call center WF- Call Center, is in Warszawa, Poland. The team provides Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Milanówek, Poland
Services provided
Zielinet is a midsize Milanówek, Poland-based answering service company. Their services include Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Norwood, MA
Services provided
HMI Performance Incentives is a Marketing Strategy company founded in 1980. The agency offers Marketing Strategy and Back Office Outsourcing, and is midsize.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Boston, MA
Services provided
Alyce is a Boston, Massachusetts-based Marketing Strategy company. Their services include Marketing Strategy and Back Office Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Marlborough, MA
Services provided
BCS CallProcessing Inc. Is a Back Office Outsourcing company. Their team is based in Marlborough, Massachusetts and focuses on Back Office Outsourcing and Call Center Services.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Cluj-Napoca, Romania
Services provided
Reashore is a Back Office Outsourcing company. They are headquartered in Cluj-Napoca, Romania and have midsize team of experts. Their services include Back Office Outsourcing and Call Center
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Richardson, TX
Services provided
CNET Global Solutions, Inc is a software development company. The team focuses on Custom Software Development and cloud consulting & SI and is located in Richardson, Texas.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Ciudad Obregón, Mexico
Services provided
Colloquium BPO is a call center. Their midsize team is headquartered in Tucson, Arizona and Ciudad Obregón, Mexico. Their services include Call Center Services and Back Office Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Lima, Peru
Services provided
Smartech BPO is a telephone answering service. They are headquartered in Lima, Peru and have midsize team. Their team provides Call Center Services and Back Office Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Ellicott City, MD
Services provided
Grindstone Sales Support Experts is an Email Marketing company. They are located in Ellicott City, Maryland and have midsize team. They specialize in Email Marketing and Back Office Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Lisboa, Portugal
Services provided
Ventask is a telephone answering service. Launched in 2015, the team provides Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Guaynabo, Puerto Rico
Services provided
Launched in 1990, DRSI CALL CENTER, LLC is a Customer Service Outsourcing company. In Guaynabo, Puerto Rico, the team specializes in Customer Service Outsourcing and Sales Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Helsinki, Finland
Services provided
Phone answering service Dynava Oy was founded in 1978. The team specializes in Call Center Services and Back Office Outsourcing and is headquartered in Helsinki, Finland.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Kingston, Jamaica
Services provided
Based in Kingston, Jamaica, City BPO is a midsize call center service. Their services include Call Center Services and Back Office Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249
Services provided
Tactical Development Solutions Ltd is an answering service. Based in Old Harbour, Jamaica, their midsize team offers Call Center Services and Back Office Outsourcing. The firm was launched in 2017.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249
Services provided
Established in 2018, Latouche Solutions is a call center service. The team offers Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing and is based in St. Ann , Jamaica.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249AAP, Argentina
Services provided
Conexus S.A. Is an AAP, Argentina-based IT staff augmentation company. They offer IT staff augmentation and Custom Software Development and were established in 2000.
Read more -
$1,000+$25 - $49 / hr50 - 249San Pedro, Philippines
Services provided
FilWeb Asia Inc is a Customer Service Outsourcing company. The San Pedro, Philippines-based firm provides Customer Service Outsourcing and Call Center Services.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Málaga, Spain
Services provided
BUKIT BPO is a call center. They were launched in 2014, and their services include Call Center Services and Back Office Outsourcing.
Read more -
$1,000+< $25 / hr50 - 249Norwich, England
Services provided
OpenContact, a telephone answering service, was launched in 2000. The team offers Call Center Services and Back Office Outsourcing and is based in Norwich, England.
Read more -
Undisclosed< $25 / hr50 - 249
Services provided
See all 6 projectsAdentcom Contact Center & BPO is a Customer Service BPO that specializes in outsourced customer support and call center solutions. With a focus on customer care outsourcing, their reviews highlight exceptional responsiveness and cultural alignment, with 100% positive feedback on project management and communication. Impressively, 100% of reviewers found their personnel caring and effective, ensuring client satisfaction.
-
$1,000+< $25 / hr50 - 249Edmonton, Canada
Services provided
Cititel Inc is a call center service. The company is based in Edmonton, Canada. Their team focuses on Call Center Services and Back Office Outsourcing.
Read more -
$1,000+< $25 / hr50 - 249Langley City, Canada
Services provided
Personal Touch, a Back Office Outsourcing company, was launched in 1982. The agency offers Back Office Outsourcing and Call Center Services.
Read more -
$1,000+< $25 / hr50 - 249Beverly, MA
Services provided
Blue Vase Marketing, a graphic design company, was launched in 2009. The agency focuses on Graphic Design and Call Center Services, and is midsize.
Read more -
$1,000+< $25 / hr50 - 249Prague, Czech Republic
Services provided
Comdata Czech is a call center company located in Prague, Czech Republic. Established in 1987, the team specializes in Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing.
Read more -
$1,000+$25 - $49 / hr50 - 249Beograd, Serbia
Services provided
EURODESK, an answering service company, was founded in 2011. The team offers Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing and is located in Beograd, Serbia.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249New York, NY
Services provided
Founded in 1922, MPC Call Centers is a telephone answering service. Their services include Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Rochester, NY
Services provided
Park Ridge Answering Service is a call center. The Rochester, New York-based agency was founded in 1970. Their services include Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Berkeley, CA
Services provided
New Connections is a midsize Berkeley, California-based call center. Their services include Call Center Services and Customer Service Outsourcing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249
Services provided
Telephone Care Company is a midsize Saudi Arabia-based custom software development company. Their services include Custom Software Development and Call Center Services.
Read more
Share your project goals, and we’ll connect you with verified partners who fit your budget and timeline.
Get My Matches
Tell us what you need — we’ll match you with top agencies in minutes.
Get My MatchesWhy Trust Clutch
At Clutch, we believe trust is the foundation of every business relationship. Our mission is to help buyers make confident, data-backed decisions informed by real client experiences.
Every review on Clutch undergoes a rigorous, human-led verification process to make sure it’s valid. Our team of specialists confirms the identity of each reviewer, ensures the project is legitimate, and only publishes reviews that meet our strict criteria.
Verification doesn’t stop at the point of publication. Our Trust & Safety team routinely audits older reviews against our guidelines. When reviews fall short of our standards, we remove them.
We evaluate service providers using a structured methodology that combines:
- In-depth client interviews and ratings
- Comprehensive project details
- Market presence
- Portfolio examples and industry recognition
This data powers tools like the Leaders Matrix, which helps you compare agencies directly. Our research team curates rankings by weighing verified reviews most heavily, so the most trusted and experienced providers rise to the top.
Using this unique combination of verified client feedback and provider-supplied insights, Clutch distills the most important details into clear, digestible summaries so you have everything you need to make confident, informed decisions quickly.
We take fraud seriously. Providers who violate our guidelines may face lower rankings, restricted visibility, or removal from the platform altogether.
Clutch’s commitment to transparency is ongoing. We’re constantly refining our systems to protect the integrity of reviews and support you in finding the right agency.
Best Customer Service Outsourcing Companies
-
$1,000+< $25 / hr1,000 - 9,999Wilmington, DE
Ability to deliver
39.4/40.020/20 Reviews9.6/10 Clients & Experience9.8/10 Market PresenceService focus
35% Customer Service Outsourcing65% Other -
$10,000+< $25 / hr250 - 999San Pablo City, Philippines
Ability to deliver
38.7/40.020/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience8.7/10 Market PresenceService focus
40% Customer Service Outsourcing60% Other -
$1,000+< $25 / hr250 - 999Kyiv, Ukraine
Ability to deliver
37.5/40.018.6/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience8.9/10 Market PresenceService focus
50% Customer Service Outsourcing50% Other -
$1,000+< $25 / hr1,000 - 9,999Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
37.5/40.018.6/20 Reviews9.4/10 Clients & Experience9.5/10 Market PresenceService focus
25% Customer Service Outsourcing75% Other -
$5,000+< $25 / hr1,000 - 9,999Lexington, KY
Ability to deliver
36.7/40.017/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.7/10 Market PresenceService focus
60% Customer Service Outsourcing40% Other -
$1,000+< $25 / hr250 - 999Dnipro, Ukraine
Ability to deliver
36.4/40.016.8/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.6/10 Market PresenceService focus
55% Customer Service Outsourcing45% Other -
$1,000+< $25 / hr1,000 - 9,999Gilbert, AZ
Ability to deliver
38.8/40.019.2/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.6/10 Market PresenceService focus
15% Customer Service Outsourcing85% Other -
$1,000+< $25 / hr10 - 49Manila, Philippines
Ability to deliver
35.9/40.018.4/20 Reviews9.8/10 Clients & Experience7.7/10 Market PresenceService focus
75% Customer Service Outsourcing25% Other -
$1,000+< $25 / hr1,000 - 9,999Angeles, Philippines
Ability to deliver
35.6/40.017/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience8.6/10 Market PresenceService focus
30% Customer Service Outsourcing70% Other -
$1,000+< $25 / hr50 - 249Afton, WY
Ability to deliver
35.5/40.018.6/20 Reviews7.1/10 Clients & Experience9.7/10 Market PresenceService focus
65% Customer Service Outsourcing35% Other -
$1,000+< $25 / hr50 - 249Sugar Land, TX
Ability to deliver
38.1/40.020/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience8.1/10 Market PresenceService focus
30% Customer Service Outsourcing70% Other -
$1,000+Undisclosed1,000 - 9,999Santa Monica, CA
Ability to deliver
35.4/40.015.8/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.6/10 Market PresenceService focus
50% Customer Service Outsourcing50% Other -
Undisclosed< $25 / hr1,000 - 9,999Boise, ID
Ability to deliver
35.3/40.015.8/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.5/10 Market PresenceService focus
60% Customer Service Outsourcing40% Other -
$1,000+< $25 / hr250 - 999Portland, OR
Ability to deliver
39.6/40.019.8/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.8/10 Market PresenceService focus
10% Customer Service Outsourcing90% Other -
$1,000+< $25 / hr1,000 - 9,999Hollywood, FL
Ability to deliver
38.9/40.020/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience8.9/10 Market PresenceService focus
10% Customer Service Outsourcing90% Other -
$1,000+< $25 / hr250 - 999
Ability to deliver
34.9/40.017.2/20 Reviews7.9/10 Clients & Experience9.7/10 Market PresenceService focus
55% Customer Service Outsourcing45% Other -
$1,000+Undisclosed250 - 999Brooklyn, NY
Ability to deliver
34.8/40.020/20 Reviews8.6/10 Clients & Experience6.2/10 Market PresenceService focus
80% Customer Service Outsourcing20% Other -
$1,000+< $25 / hr250 - 999Hatboro, PA
Ability to deliver
35.3/40.017.6/20 Reviews8.7/10 Clients & Experience9/10 Market PresenceService focus
30% Customer Service Outsourcing70% Other -
$5,000+$25 - $49 / hr50 - 249Austin, TX
Ability to deliver
34.4/40.017.6/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience6.8/10 Market PresenceService focus
50% Customer Service Outsourcing50% Other -
$10,000+< $25 / hr10,000+Pasig, Philippines
Ability to deliver
34.2/40.014.6/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.6/10 Market PresenceService focus
30% Customer Service Outsourcing70% Other -
$5,000+< $25 / hr1,000 - 9,999Cebu City, Philippines
Ability to deliver
34.2/40.017.4/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience6.8/10 Market PresenceService focus
30% Customer Service Outsourcing70% Other -
$5,000+$25 - $49 / hr250 - 999Home, KS
Ability to deliver
34.2/40.016.8/20 Reviews9.2/10 Clients & Experience8.2/10 Market PresenceService focus
40% Customer Service Outsourcing60% Other -
$10,000+< $25 / hr1,000 - 9,999Cambridge, MA
Ability to deliver
34.1/40.018.2/20 Reviews8.5/10 Clients & Experience7.5/10 Market PresenceService focus
70% Customer Service Outsourcing30% Other -
$50,000+< $25 / hr10,000+Wei Fang Shi, China
Ability to deliver
34.1/40.015.8/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience8.3/10 Market PresenceService focus
50% Customer Service Outsourcing50% Other -
$1,000+< $25 / hr250 - 999
Ability to deliver
34.6/40.016.4/20 Reviews9.3/10 Clients & Experience8.9/10 Market PresenceService focus
30% Customer Service Outsourcing70% Other -
$5,000+< $25 / hr50 - 249Cairo, Egypt
Ability to deliver
36.6/40.018.4/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience8.2/10 Market PresenceService focus
30% Customer Service Outsourcing70% Other -
$10,000+Undisclosed250 - 999Nijmegen, Netherlands
Ability to deliver
33.6/40.016.2/20 Reviews9.7/10 Clients & Experience7.7/10 Market PresenceService focus
45% Customer Service Outsourcing55% Other -
$1,000+< $25 / hr250 - 999Amsterdam, Netherlands
Ability to deliver
33.2/40.016.4/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience6.8/10 Market PresenceService focus
45% Customer Service Outsourcing55% Other -
$1,000+$25 - $49 / hr250 - 999Orlando, FL
Ability to deliver
35.5/40.016.4/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.1/10 Market PresenceService focus
20% Customer Service Outsourcing80% Other -
UndisclosedUndisclosed1,000 - 9,999Los Angeles, CA
Ability to deliver
34.1/40.016.6/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience7.5/10 Market PresenceService focus
20% Customer Service Outsourcing80% Other
Customer Support Outsourcing FAQs
Freelancers can fill short-term gaps but often lack management structure, QA processes, and redundant staffing. A dedicated customer support outsourcing company provides dedicated leadership, scalability, and established SLAs—crucial for brands that need consistent, round-the-clock coverage.
E-commerce, SaaS, fintech, travel, and healthcare commonly leverage outsourced teams to handle seasonal spikes, global user bases, or specialized compliance requirements.
A customer support outsourcing company acts as an external help desk, handling inbound and outbound interactions across phone, chat, email, social media, and other channels. These agencies make sure scripts align with brand guidelines and KPIs for optimal effectiveness. Moreover, they also handle the recruitment, training, and management of experienced agents who will be in charge of resolving tickets, processing orders, and providing technical assistance on behalf of the client. Ultimately, their main goal is to maintain—or improve—customer satisfaction while reducing overhead and expanding service coverage.
Customer support outsourcing companies don’t just provide one-size-fits-all solutions; they tailor their strategies and approach to help businesses provide the best support to their customers. When partnering with a full-service provider, clients can expect services such as:
- Voice, chat, and email support (Tier 1–3)
- Technical troubleshooting and product onboarding
- Order processing, refunds, and billing inquiries
- Social media moderation and community management
- Multilingual or 24/7 coverage
- Quality assurance, analytics, and CSAT reporting
Many agencies also bundle back-office tasks such as data entry or CRM administration to create an end-to-end customer operations solution.
Most customer service outsourcing projects reviewed on Clutch range from $10,000 – $49,999. Pricing depends on various factors such as agent location, language skills, and complexity of support. Here’s a rundown of average costs:
- Shared agents: $8–$15 per hour (often offshore)
- Dedicated agents: $15–$30 per hour for mid-tier markets
- Specialized or technical agents in high-cost regions: $30–$50+ per hour
When preparing a budget, ensure you have a clear understanding of your project and which factors impact pricing. Always confirm whether fees include training, software licenses, and quality monitoring.
- Map your project’s unique requirements—channels, hours, volumes, and languages.
- Shortlist vendors with proven experience in your industry and ticket complexity.
- Review verified client ratings, case studies, and sample reports on Clutch to evaluate performance metrics such as first-contact resolution or NPS lifts.
- Assess cultural fit—communication cadence, escalation procedures, and data-security standards.
- Schedule a discovery call or an interview to thoroughly discuss your project and get to know more about their services.
- Run a pilot or SLA-backed trial before signing a long-term contract.
- Guaranteed CSAT scores without a clear methodology
- Vague pricing or hidden setup fees
- High agent turnover rates or lack of training documentation
- Limited transparency into QA scores or call recordings
- Poor data-security certifications (e.g., no ISO/PCI compliance)
- How do you recruit, train, and retain agents for my account?
- Which tools (CRM, ticketing, QA) do you use, and can you integrate with ours?
- What are your average response and resolution times for clients like us?
- How is performance reported, and how often can we audit calls/chats?
- What is your disaster-recovery and data-protection policy?
- Can we start with a pilot program, and how is success defined?