Top Digital Marketing Agencies in Chicago
Chicago’s bustling tech scene—anchored by hubs like 1871, Fulton Market, and the campuses of Northwestern and U of C—has spawned a thriving ecosystem of digital marketing talent. From data-driven web marketing agencies in the Loop to full-service firms in River North, the city offers specialists who know how to reach Midwestern consumers and global audiences alike.
Clutch simplifies your search by collecting in-depth client interviews, transparent ratings, and service details you won’t find elsewhere. Use our filters to sort Chicago marketing firms by hourly rate, industry expertise, or project size, then read verified reviews to make a confident hiring decision.
Need to find the perfect partner? Explore the global directory of Top Digital Marketing Companies, compare Midwest neighbors via Milwaukee digital marketing agencies, or find Chicago specialists for healthcare marketing thorugh a narrowed search of Chicago marketing agencies specialized in healthcare.
What to boost your website or create a tailored web presence to match your digital marketing efforts? Explore the top web design companies in Chicago.
-
Featured
What are Featured Providers?
$1,000+$50 - $99 / hr50 - 249Serves Chicago, ILServices provided
See all 112 projectsFunnel Boost Media is a digital marketing firm specializing in SEO, website development, and PPC management. They consistently receive high praise for their project management, timely delivery, and exceptional customer service. Across their reviews, 100% of clients commend their communication and ability to tailor solutions effectively, with no significant areas for improvement noted.
$5,000+$100 - $149 / hr10 - 49Serves Chicago, ILServices provided
See all 2 projectsThrivePOP is a woman-owned marketing agency specializing in digital branding, website development, and e-commerce solutions. They have received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with clients praising their creativity, strategic approach, and excellent project management. Around 100% of reviewers highlighted ThrivePOP's ability to align with their business values and deliver exceptional results, including increased sales and improved brand presence.
$5,000+$150 - $199 / hr50 - 249Serves Chicago, ILServices provided
See all 365 projectsDisruptive Advertising is a full-service digital marketing agency specializing in PPC management, SEO, and SEM services. The overall feedback from their reviews is largely positive, with 87% of clients praising their expertise, communication, and personalized approach, often highlighting their ability to act as an extension of their clients' teams. However, one review noted dissatisfaction with their handling of large marketing budgets, suggesting potential limitations for high-budget projects.
$1,000+Undisclosed250 - 999Serves Chicago, ILServices provided
See all 147 projectsIntero Digital is a digital marketing agency specializing in SEO, content marketing, digital PR, web design, and paid media strategies. The company receives predominantly positive feedback, with approximately 75% of reviews highlighting their strategic and responsive project management. However, a minority of reviews, around 25%, criticize their execution and communication, indicating areas for improvement.
-
$10,000+$100 - $149 / hr2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
Kreate Digital is an UX design company. Based in Chicago, Illinois, the agency was established in 2013. Their team offers UX/UI Design and Web Design.
Read more -
Undisclosed$150 - $199 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Services provided
Multiple Inc. Is a branding firm. Launched in 2013, the team specializes in Branding and Print Design. The agency is located in Chicago, Illinois and.
Read more -
Featured
What are Featured Providers?
$50,000+$150 - $199 / hr10 - 49Serves Chicago, ILServices provided
See all 16 projectsHotspex Media is a digital marketing agency specializing in omnichannel digital and traditional media services, including paid social media, search engine marketing, SEO, and campaign strategy. The company has received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with a notable emphasis on their exceptional project management and deep industry knowledge. Approximately 90% of reviewers commend their ability to deliver impressive results and maintain clear communication, while several appreciate their consultative approach and innovative insights.
-
$1,000+$25 - $49 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Services provided
369 Digital is a web development company. Their small team is based in Chicago, Illinois and provides Web Development and UX/UI Design. The agency was founded in 2020.
Read more -
$10,000+$200 - $300 / hr2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
Local Legend Films is a video production company. Their small team is headquartered in Chicago, Illinois and offers Video Production and Content Marketing. The agency was founded in 2018.
Read more -
$1,000+< $25 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Services provided
Cogito software is a Logo company established in 2016. The team offers Logo and Print Design and is headquartered in Chicago, Illinois.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
Spanish+Media is a branding firm. Headquartered in Chicago, Illinois, the agency focuses on Branding and Marketing Strategy.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
The Fund Lab is a Marketing Strategy company based in Chicago, Illinois. Their services include Marketing Strategy and Social Media Marketing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
Digital Brandworks, an Advertising company, was founded in 2013. They specializes in Advertising and Content Marketing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
MyWHY Agency, Inc. Is a branding firm. The Chicago, Illinois-based team provides Branding and Public Relations.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
Magnolia Insights, a branding firm, was established in 2014. The firm offers Branding and Marketing Strategy.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
Founded in 2011, Yasha Sterling Management Agency is a SEO agency. The agency focuses on Search Engine Optimization and E-Commerce Development, and is small.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed2 - 9Evanston, IL
Services provided
Located in Evanston, Illinois, neXt Brand Partners is a small social media marketing agency. The team focuses on Social Media Marketing and Search Engine Optimization.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
Connections Marketing is a branding agency. Headquartered in Chicago, Illinois, the company was founded in 2009. Their team offers Branding and Media Planning & Buying.
Read more -
$5,000+Undisclosed10 - 49Chicago, IL
Services provided
Production Craft is a video production company. They are headquartered in Chicago, Illinois, and their services include Video Production and Broadcast Video.
Read more -
$10,000+$50 - $99 / hr2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
Devfollow is an IT strategy consulting company. Established in 2024, the firm is located in Chicago, Illinois. Their team offers IT strategy consulting and Custom Software Development.
Read more -
$5,000+$150 - $199 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Services provided
Mediaspace is a web design company. They offer Web Design and Web Development and were founded in 2020.
Read more -
$1,000+$100 - $149 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Services provided
ChicagoSEO.Company is an Advertising company founded in 2007. Their services include Advertising and Branding.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed10 - 49Chicago, IL
Services provided
Headquartered in Chicago, Illinois, OutCold is an Event Marketing company. They focus on Event Marketing and Marketing Strategy and were launched in 2010.
Read more -
$5,000+$100 - $149 / hr10 - 49Lincolnshire, IL
Services provided
See all 13 projectsMore Local Clients LLC is a digital marketing agency specializing in website development, SEO, and branding services. The company consistently receives positive feedback, with approximately 100% of reviews highlighting their professionalism, timely project delivery, and strong communication skills. Many clients commend their SEO expertise, with around 80% noting significant improvements in web rankings and lead generation.
-
$5,000+$150 - $199 / hr2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
See all 1 projectsWebosition is a Strategic Digital Positioning firm dedicated to empowering businesses from inception to scale through cohesive Business Launch, Brand Identity, Digital Architecture, and Conversion
Read more -
$5,000+$150 - $199 / hr2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
See all 1 projectsThrei Strategy offers branding and web development services. The overall feedback indicates dissatisfaction, highlighting issues with professionalism, communication, and skill levels. Clients report delayed responses and unprofessional conduct, suggesting significant room for improvement in project management and client interaction.
-
Undisclosed$25 - $49 / hr2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
Launched in 2025, DS Collective is a small SEO services firm. Their team offers Search Engine Optimization and UX/UI Design.
Read more -
$1,000+$25 - $49 / hr2 - 9Glen Ellyn, IL
Services provided
Tech Hive Digitals is a SEO company founded in 2025. The team provides Search Engine Optimization and Web Design.
Read more -
$5,000+$150 - $199 / hr2 - 9Evanston, IL
Services provided
Branding agency Gridhaus Studio offers Branding and Marketing Strategy. They were launched in 2025.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed10 - 49Chicago, IL
Services provided
Launched in 1988, CIVILIAN Agency, a small Marketing Strategy company, is headquartered in Chicago, Illinois. Their team focuses on Marketing Strategy and Advertising.
Read more -
$1,000+$100 - $149 / hr2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
Paramount Public Relations is a public relations firm. Located in Chicago, Illinois, the company was launched in 2003. Their team focuses on Public Relations and Event Marketing.
Read more -
$1,000+$50 - $99 / hr2 - 9Elk Grove Village, IL
Services provided
Web design agency J Printing Center Chicago Inc was established in 2015. The company provides Web Design and Branding, and is small.
Read more -
$1,000+$150 - $199 / hr2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
See all 1 projectsMagpie Creative is a boutique, woman and LGBTQ+ owned Chicago-based creative production studio specializing in video production, content strategy, and social media managmenet in the sports,
Read more -
$10,000+$100 - $149 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Services provided
SOCIALDEVIANT is an Advertising company in Chicago, Illinois. Their services include Advertising and Branding.
Read more -
$5,000+$100 - $149 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Services provided
Vis-a-vis Creative is a SEO company headquartered in Chicago, Illinois. The team provides Search Engine Optimization and Web Design.
Read more -
$5,000+$100 - $149 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Services provided
Treacy Marketing Group is a SEO services firm. Their small team is headquartered in Chicago, Illinois. Their services include Search Engine Optimization and Web Design.
Read more -
$5,000+$100 - $149 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Services provided
Established in 2006, ClearEdge Marketing is a SEO services firm. Their team provides Search Engine Optimization and Advertising.
Read more -
$5,000+$100 - $149 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Services provided
EM Search Consulting is a Chicago, Illinois-based SEO company. They specialize in Search Engine Optimization and Web Design.
Read more -
$1,000+$25 - $49 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Services provided
M2 Digital Media Group is a web design company. Launched in 2005, the company focuses on Web Design and Video Production.
Read more -
$5,000+$100 - $149 / hr10 - 49Skokie, IL
Services provided
GLC, an Advertising company, was launched in 1969. The team focuses on Advertising and Search Engine Optimization.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed10 - 49Chicago, IL
Services provided
TE+A Marketing is a branding firm established in 1985. The agency focuses on Branding and Market Research, and is small.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed10 - 49Oak Brook, IL
Services provided
Social Integration, an Advertising company, was launched in 2011. The company offers Advertising and Email Marketing, and is small.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed10 - 49Chicago, IL
Services provided
UkrInSofT is an UX company. Their small team is headquartered in Stebnyk, Ukraine and Chicago, Illinois. Their services include UX/UI Design and Web Development.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed10 - 49Skokie, IL
Services provided
Wizspeed is a social media marketing company. The Skokie, Illinois-based company specializes in Social Media Marketing and Email Marketing.
Read more -
$1,000+$25 - $49 / hr10 - 49Glen Ellyn, IL
Services provided
See all 9 projectsAva Digital Agency is a versatile digital marketing company specializing in website development, SEO, and social media management. Clients report high satisfaction with the agency's strategic approach, responsiveness, and delivery, with 100% of reviews praising their professionalism and timely project management. Key strengths include innovative problem-solving and the ability to significantly boost online visibility and sales.
-
$5,000+$100 - $149 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Services provided
GoodFolk is a branding company. Founded in 2015, the firm specializes in Branding and Digital Strategy.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
Slim Marty is an Email Marketing company. In Chicago, Illinois, the team specializes in Email Marketing and Pay Per Click.
Read more -
$5,000+$100 - $149 / hr2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
Smarty Media, a PPC company, offer Pay Per Click and Conversion Optimization. They were launched in 2009.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
Small public relations agency Kaye Publicity, is in Chicago, Illinois. The team focuses on Public Relations and Branding.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
Activate Hype is a small Advertising company established in 2018. Their services include Advertising and Branding.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed2 - 9Evanston, IL
Services provided
Allegra Marketing Print Signs is a Direct Marketing company. They were founded in 2001 and offer Direct Marketing and Content Marketing.
Read more -
UndisclosedUndisclosed2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
AdPulse Media, LLC, an Advertising company, specializes in Advertising and Media Planning & Buying. The firm is located in Chicago, Illinois.
Read more -
$1,000+Undisclosed2 - 9Skokie, IL
Services provided
Al Badsha is a small web design agency based in Dubai, United Arab Emirates and Hyderabad, India. Their services include Web Design and Social Media Marketing.
Read more -
$25,000+$150 - $199 / hr50 - 249Chicago, IL
Services provided
In Chicago, Illinois, SEO Notch is a SEO agency. They provide Search Engine Optimization and Web Development and were launched in 2022.
Read more -
$25,000+$150 - $199 / hr2 - 9Chicago, IL
Services provided
Digital Strategy company DesignScout | A Branding Agency was founded in 2003. The agency specializes in Digital Strategy and Logo.
Read more
Share your project goals, and we’ll connect you with verified partners who fit your budget and timeline.
Get My Matches
Tell us what you need — we’ll match you with top agencies in minutes.
Get My MatchesWhy Trust Clutch
At Clutch, we believe trust is the foundation of every business relationship. Our mission is to help buyers make confident, data-backed decisions informed by real client experiences.
Every review on Clutch undergoes a rigorous, human-led verification process to make sure it’s valid. Our team of specialists confirms the identity of each reviewer, ensures the project is legitimate, and only publishes reviews that meet our strict criteria.
Verification doesn’t stop at the point of publication. Our Trust & Safety team routinely audits older reviews against our guidelines. When reviews fall short of our standards, we remove them.
We evaluate service providers using a structured methodology that combines:
- In-depth client interviews and ratings
- Comprehensive project details
- Market presence
- Portfolio examples and industry recognition
This data powers tools like the Leaders Matrix, which helps you compare agencies directly. Our research team curates rankings by weighing verified reviews most heavily, so the most trusted and experienced providers rise to the top.
Using this unique combination of verified client feedback and provider-supplied insights, Clutch distills the most important details into clear, digestible summaries so you have everything you need to make confident, informed decisions quickly.
We take fraud seriously. Providers who violate our guidelines may face lower rankings, restricted visibility, or removal from the platform altogether.
Clutch’s commitment to transparency is ongoing. We’re constantly refining our systems to protect the integrity of reviews and support you in finding the right agency.
List of the Top 15 Chicago Digital Marketing Companies
-
$5,000+$150 - $199 / hr50 - 249Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
38.8/40.019/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.8/10 Market PresenceService focus
100% Digital Marketing -
$1,000+$100 - $149 / hr50 - 249Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
37.9/40.018/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.9/10 Market PresenceService focus
95% Digital Marketing5% Other -
$5,000+$200 - $300 / hr50 - 249Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
37.5/40.019/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience8.5/10 Market PresenceService focus
85% Digital Marketing15% Other -
$10,000+$100 - $149 / hr50 - 249Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
36.9/40.018.2/20 Reviews9.6/10 Clients & Experience9.2/10 Market PresenceService focus
45% Digital Marketing55% Other -
$5,000+$150 - $199 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
38.2/40.018.6/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.6/10 Market PresenceService focus
45% Digital Marketing55% Other -
$10,000+$150 - $199 / hr10 - 49Northfield, IL
Ability to deliver
36.3/40.016.8/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.5/10 Market PresenceService focus
85% Digital Marketing15% Other -
UndisclosedUndisclosed50 - 249Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
34.6/40.015.6/20 Reviews9.4/10 Clients & Experience9.6/10 Market PresenceService focus
50% Digital Marketing50% Other -
$5,000+$200 - $300 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
36.2/40.017.4/20 Reviews9.2/10 Clients & Experience9.6/10 Market PresenceService focus
50% Digital Marketing50% Other -
$1,000+$100 - $149 / hr2 - 9Oakbrook Terrace, IL
Ability to deliver
36.6/40.017/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.6/10 Market PresenceService focus
100% Digital Marketing -
UndisclosedUndisclosed250 - 999Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
30.4/40.014.6/20 Reviews7.8/10 Clients & Experience8/10 Market PresenceService focus
70% Digital Marketing30% Other -
$1,000+$150 - $199 / hr2 - 9Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
35.8/40.016.8/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9/10 Market PresenceService focus
60% Digital Marketing40% Other -
$1,000+$200 - $300 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
34.2/40.017/20 Reviews7.2/10 Clients & Experience10/10 Market PresenceService focus
80% Digital Marketing20% Other -
$50,000+$150 - $199 / hr50 - 249Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
39/40.020/20 Reviews9.1/10 Clients & Experience10/10 Market PresenceService focus
25% Digital Marketing75% Other -
$1,000+$100 - $149 / hr50 - 249Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
37/40.017.2/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.8/10 Market PresenceService focus
90% Digital Marketing10% Other -
$1,000+$100 - $149 / hr2 - 9Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
32.3/40.017.4/20 Reviews8.4/10 Clients & Experience6.6/10 Market PresenceService focus
90% Digital Marketing10% Other -
$5,000+$150 - $199 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
38/40.019.2/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience8.8/10 Market PresenceService focus
30% Digital Marketing70% Other -
$1,000+$100 - $149 / hr10 - 49Elmhurst, IL
Ability to deliver
39.1/40.019.8/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.3/10 Market PresenceService focus
20% Digital Marketing80% Other -
$10,000+$150 - $199 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
35.5/40.015.8/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.7/10 Market PresenceService focus
40% Digital Marketing60% Other -
$1,000+< $25 / hr50 - 249Lombard, IL
Ability to deliver
40/40.020/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience10/10 Market PresenceService focus
10% Digital Marketing90% Other -
$5,000+$50 - $99 / hr50 - 249Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
39.7/40.020/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.7/10 Market PresenceService focus
10% Digital Marketing90% Other -
$50,000+Undisclosed250 - 999Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
32.5/40.015.6/20 Reviews9/10 Clients & Experience7.9/10 Market PresenceService focus
30% Digital Marketing70% Other -
$5,000+$150 - $199 / hr2 - 9Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
32.4/40.015.6/20 Reviews9.7/10 Clients & Experience7.1/10 Market PresenceService focus
80% Digital Marketing20% Other -
$1,000+$100 - $149 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
30.4/40.015.8/20 Reviews8.8/10 Clients & Experience5.8/10 Market PresenceService focus
80% Digital Marketing20% Other -
$25,000+$100 - $149 / hr1,000 - 9,999Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
35.2/40.016/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.2/10 Market PresenceService focus
20% Digital Marketing80% Other -
$5,000+$150 - $199 / hr50 - 249Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
30.9/40.016.4/20 Reviews9.1/10 Clients & Experience5.5/10 Market PresenceService focus
51% Digital Marketing49% Other -
$5,000+$150 - $199 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
29.7/40.017.2/20 Reviews5.6/10 Clients & Experience6.9/10 Market PresenceService focus
100% Digital Marketing -
$75,000+$150 - $199 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
37/40.017.4/20 Reviews10/10 Clients & Experience9.6/10 Market PresenceService focus
20% Digital Marketing80% Other -
$1,000+$50 - $99 / hr50 - 249Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
32.3/40.020/20 Reviews5.7/10 Clients & Experience6.7/10 Market PresenceService focus
40% Digital Marketing60% Other -
$5,000+$150 - $199 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
30/40.016.2/20 Reviews7.4/10 Clients & Experience6.4/10 Market PresenceService focus
60% Digital Marketing40% Other -
$5,000+$150 - $199 / hr10 - 49Chicago, IL
Ability to deliver
29.8/40.016.4/20 Reviews6.8/10 Clients & Experience6.6/10 Market PresenceService focus
70% Digital Marketing30% Other
Latest Digital Marketing Articles
See all articles
When To Use Video vs. Written Content: A Topic-by-Topic Guide
Video vs. written content isn't black or white. Data shows that 72% prefer video for how-tos, but just 17% for financial advice. When should your brand use...
Chicago Digital Marketing Agency FAQs
Working with a local team provides game-changing advantages that can level up your project, including:
- In-market insights: agencies understand Chicago’s commuter patterns, seasonal events (think Lollapalooza, the Chicago Marathon), and media outlets.
- Face-to-face collaboration: easy to meet in the Loop or West Loop for strategy sessions.
- Access to Midwest talent: local universities produce top creatives and data analysts, often more cost-effective than coastal counterparts.
If your target audience spans Illinois or the Great Lakes region, a Chicago partner can be a strategic advantage.
Budgets for hiring a Chicago-based digital marketing agency vary based on factors such as team size, creative requirements, and scope. According to Clutch data, clients can expect:
- Hourly rates: $100 – $149 for senior-level, $50 – $99 for boutique teams
- Monthly retainers: $4,000 – $15,000 for multi-channel campaigns
- Project-based work: Site audits or one-off PPC tests can start around $5,000
Chicago pricing often lands below New York or San Francisco while delivering comparable expertise. Remember, ask for a detailed quote for your project so you can avoid unexpected costs and financial strain.
Thanks to the city’s diverse economy, experienced digital marketing agencies frequently specialize in a multitude of markets and niches such as:
- Finance and fintech
- Healthcare and med-tech (the Illinois Medical District)
- Manufacturing and logistics
- Food and beverage (home to Kraft Heinz, Conagra)
- Higher education and nonprofits
Many full-service digital marketing agencies also maintain cross-industry teams for B2B SaaS, e-commerce, and sports/entertainment.
- Define goals—lead gen, brand awareness, e-commerce sales.
- Shortlist agencies with relevant case studies and industry accolades.
- Review Clutch profiles for verified feedback, team size, and tech stack.
- Schedule discovery calls; ask about KPIs, reporting cadence, and Chicago-specific success stories.
- Start with a pilot project or 3-month retainer to gauge fit.
- One-size-fits-all proposals that ignore your niche or local competitors
- Lack of transparency in pricing or media spend markup
- Overpromising quick SEO rankings or guaranteed follower counts
- No Chicago presence despite a “local” listing—verify a real office or team members in the area
- Limited reporting or unwillingness to share raw data