Why One-Size-Fits-All Influencer Marketing No Longer Works

Influencer marketing has grown massively over the last ten years, rising from just $1.7 billion in 2015 to over $32 billion in 2025. The industry’s maturation has created several tiers of influencers for brands to partner with, from small accounts with under 10,000 followers to celebrity pages with millions.

The emergence of these different types of influencers has created new marketing opportunities. But you’ll need tailored strategies to take advantage of them. The one-size-fits-all approach that worked in the early days of influencer marketing tends to fall flat today in the age of social media.

In a recent Clutch survey of 277 consumers, we found that nearly 50% of consumers haven't purchased a product based on an influencer's recommendation in the past year. But it was clear that different tiers of influencers are attractive to people who do take influencer recommendations seriously.

This guide will help you decide which influencer types (macro influencers, micro influencers, nano influencers) your business should work with and which strategies are most effective for each.

Types of Influencers

Let’s take a closer look at the main categories of influencers your brand may want to partner with. These influencer tiers are based on size. But you may also want to experiment with groupings based on social platforms, demographic differences, and other elements relevant to your goals.

Nano Influencers (1 - 10K Followers)

Nano influencers are the smallest influencers that brands work with. These accounts can have as few as a couple of hundred followers or as many as 10,000. According to Clutch data, 13% of consumers prefer product recommendations from nano influencers. This suggests that at least some of your target audience would prefer to learn about your products from small accounts they trust.

Either way, nano influencers have niche communities with high engagement rates. This makes them a good fit for niche products and authenticity-driven campaigns.

For example, a sustainable skincare brand might be preparing to enter a new state. As part of that, they could partner with a local eco-conscious nano influencer. This could help the brand connect with the niche, local community of buyers that will determine revenue in the region.

Micro Influencers (10K - 100K Followers)

Micro influencers are a middle ground between the intimacy of nano influencers and the reach of macro influencers. Clutch reports show that 20% of consumers prefer recommendations from micro influencers. This was the number one tier of the poll, showing a strong demand for these kinds of partnerships. They can help you reach more people with your message while still maintaining a strong rate of engagement.

Micro influencers are great for reaching niche communities at scale. For example, a vegan food brand might target plant-based foodies on Instagram with a series of posts from micro influencers across the community. These ads tend to deliver strong engagement rates and cost-effective exposure.

Macro Influencers (100K+ Followers)

Finally, Clutch data shows that 9% of consumers prefer recommendations from macro influencers. Macro influencers are large creators who tend to share more professional content. They’re helpful for expanding brand awareness in the communities you’re targeting.

For example, a national fitness app brand that’s launching a new app might use well-known macro fitness influencers or even celebrities to maximize visibility. These influencers are best for delivering professional content designed for mass market appeal.

The Problem With One-Size-Fits-All Influencer Marketing Strategies

First, why can’t you use the same strategy with every influencer? That would save money and make results easier to compare. However, every influencer has their own unique audience, which is important to consider for the following reasons:

• Audience size and engagement levels vary greatly: Nano influencers often get higher engagement rates at a smaller scale, while macro influencers have lower engagement rates and larger reach. Your campaign strategy should reflect the unique opportunities presented by the type of influencer you’re partnering with.
• Audience expectations differ: Fans of smaller creators expect personal, relatable content, while those following larger accounts are used to polished, professional content. This can impact the kind of branded post that resonates best with the audience.
• Platform behavior is not universal: Campaigns that perform well on TikTok may struggle on X and vice versa. You may need to revamp your messaging or approach to make it resonate across social platforms.

Ultimately, a one-size-fits-all approach leaves opportunity on the table. Tailoring your strategy on an influencer-by-influencer basis will help you get more value out of the money you spend on partnerships.

Which Type of Influencer Works Best for You?

The key takeaway is that each class of influencer has its own value proposition. You’ll get more out of your campaigns if you partner with influencers who offer advantages related to your goals. But what does that mean in practice when comparing micro vs. macro influencers, nano vs. macro influencers, and micro vs. nano influencers? We explore below.

When To Use Nano Influencers

Nano influencers offer the highest engagement rates and levels of perceived authenticity. But they have limited reach and make campaigns challenging to scale.

You should use a nano influencer when you’re:

• Targeting a specific niche or local audience
• Seeking authentic recommendations that feel like word-of-mouth advertising
• Budget is limited and want to focus on direct engagement over reach

However, you shouldn’t use a nano influencer if:

• You need to reach a large audience quickly
• You don’t have the time or resources to manage multiple influencer partnerships at once

When To Use Micro Influencers

Micro influencers offer a strong balance of reach, relatability, and engagement. But they aren’t the best for any of these, offering lower engagement per view than nano influencers and less reach than macro influencers.

You should use micro influencers when:

• You want a strong mix of reach and engagement
• You’re targeting large, defined audience segments (like wellness moms or gamers)
• You want scalable campaigns that still feel relatable

However, you shouldn’t use micro influencers when:

• You want to maximize engagement per view
• You want to maximize exposure or run large-scale, national campaigns on tight timelines

When To Use Macro Influencers

Macro influencers offer maximum exposure for your brand and polished, professional content. However, they have lower trust levels than other influencers, and you end up paying a higher cost per engagement.

You should use macro influencers when:

• You want broad brand awareness quickly
• Your campaign or brand image requires highly polished content
• You want people to associate your brand with a well-known figure for credibility

However, you shouldn’t use a macro influencer when:

• You’re promoting a very niche product or have a brand that depends on trust and relatability
• Your budget is tight, or ROI is dependent on engagement over reach

The Growing Value of Influencer Marketing Diversification

Influencer marketing has advanced significantly in the last ten years. In the past, getting an influencer to talk about your products was often enough to drive results. However, today's market is more competitive, and cutting through the noise has become more difficult.

That’s why it’s so important to diversify your approach based on the kind of influencer you’re working with and your goals. Tailored strategies, intentionally designed for the audience you’re targeting, have the best odds of success in this landscape. You can start designing those strategies yourself using the information in this guide or partner with an influencer marketing agency if you’d like some support.

About the Author

Anna Peck Content Marketing Manager at Clutch

Anna Peck is a content marketing manager at Clutch, where she crafts content on digital marketing, SEO, and public relations. In addition to editing and producing engaging B2B content, she plays a key role in Clutch’s awards program and contributed content efforts. Originally joining Clutch as part of the reviews team, she now focuses on developing SEO-driven content strategies that offer valuable insights to B2B buyers seeking the best service providers.

See full profile