PPC Engagement and Audit for Online Editing Firm
-
Search Engine Optimization
-
Content development On site optimization Other SEO
- $10,000 to $49,999
- Jan. 2016 - Ongoing
- Quality
- 5.0
- Schedule
- 4.5
- Cost
- 5.0
- Willing to Refer
- 5.0
"[T]hey were willing to analyze my needs before actually talking about a campaign.”
- Education
- Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
- 1-10 Employees
- Phone Interview
- Verified
Serving as an SEO partner, WebpageFX helped increase customer traffic to a new website. They also recommended a pay-per-click campaign as a more effective option.
WebpageFX delivered a detailed audit to steer the firm away from SEO, accommodated a request for a shorter contract, and capably handled potential issues with Google AdWords. Their Facebook campaign led to a large increase in traffic, which held potential to attract new clients.
A Clutch analyst personally interviewed this client over the phone. Below is an edited transcript.
BACKGROUND
Please describe your organization.
We are a web-based company with a team of two dozen editors, each specializing in different types of text editing, including novels, memoirs, academic and business work, and so on. Our company has been in business since 2008.
What is your position?
I am the president of the company.
OPPORTUNITY / CHALLENGE
What business challenge were you trying to address with WebpageFX?
We built a new company website and were looking to drive traffic to it.
SOLUTION
Please describe the scope of their involvement in detail.
We wanted to assess what the requirements for driving traffic to the site would be and do whatever needed to be done for this purpose. I initially contacted WebpageFX for SEO [search engine optimization] management. One of the first things that impressed me about their company was the degree of effort put into analyzing our website as well as those of our competitors, and figuring out what our needs would be. While SEO management would be something to take into account in the end, they thought that, if I invested in it right now, I would be disappointed. Given the nature of my business, they thought that I would not see a serious return on investment for at least 18 months. I was impressed by their willingness to steer me away from what would have been a ticket item.
They offered us numerous other options. Being a small company, out budget is limited, a fact of which WebpageFX was fully aware. I could have hired them to make changes for us to the website but, not only was that not the best direction for us financially but, given the nature of our business – namely writing people's web copy – we tend to be fastidious about our language. It was preferable for WebpageFX to let us know what we needed and let us write the material. They did write our ads for us. We started out with a Google AdWords campaign, and their handling of it was phenomenal. We did run into a problem in the sense that Google AdWords was blocking us. WebpageFX pursued it and found that Google was concerned about us being a paper mill. Once the site was reviewed by a human being, they discovered that we placed disclaimers, explicitly stating that we didn't engage in such activities. When it comes to academic work, we offer editing and coaching, but nothing that would be considered academically unethical. WebpageFX rolled with the punches when Google threw us for a loop.
We thought that we were moving forward, but still found ourselves up against the wall. Google stated that they were not advertising any sites offering academic editing. I was crestfallen, not knowing what we were going to do. While WebpageFX continue to pursue the problem until this day, they led us in a couple of different directions. They started a Bing pay-per-click campaign that didn't produce the kind of results I was hoping for, but they also created a targeted Facebook campaign that now seems to be the best direction.
In the middle of this, we also talked about the fact that, because we have a young website, we have a concern about its domain credibility. In order to boost that score, we're now in the process of creating a link-building campaign. WebpageFX has a couple of different ways of approaching this in their plan, but they were also willing to create a custom-designed link building campaign just for us. We haven't engaged in this, but it's something that enters into our discussions, and I envision it happening within the next couple of months [summer of 2016].
How did you come to work with WebpageFX?
The people on our team write for a couple of companies that offer SEO management. I originally thought that we'd be using one of those, but we also asked for some recommendations and made online searches, looking at reviews. WebpageFX kept coming up at the top of different lists, so much so that I became concerned that they wouldn't take us on, given our size. Fortunately, that wasn't the case.
Could you provide a sense of the size of this initiative in financial terms?
We paid an initial $1,000 setup fee, which they more than earned. The amount of background work and competitive analysis were impressive.
Initially, they wanted us to sign a 12-month contract by which we would pay them a retainer for our pay-per-click campaign of $325 per month, on top of our ad spend. This was a new step for us, and I was uncomfortable with making a 12-month commitment, but they had no problem in turning it into a six-month contract. Our ad spend is $1,000 per month on pay-per-click campaigns.
What is the status of this engagement?
We haven't been working with WebpageFX for a long time. I reached out to their company in late January 2016. They did an analysis of our site, and we began building our campaign at the middle of February. The initial plan was to launch the campaign at the beginning of March. We were held back by a couple of issues that we were trying to tweak. The campaign has only been live for less than a month so far.
RESULTS & FEEDBACK
Could you share any statistics or metrics from this engagement?
I couldn't say that we've been swamped with new clients, but I've seen steps in the right direction being made. We're getting great traffic from our Facebook campaign.
We're currently analyzing which aspects of our website are causing bounces. Our account representative has recommended some tweaks to the page, and I'm in the process of implementing them on our end. It remains to be seen if this addresses the problem. We are seeing an enormous amount of traffic, compared to what we were seeing previously. Not all of it results in new clients, but we are working with WebpageFX for improving this.
How did WebpageFX perform from a project management standpoint?
I come from an academic background, so this is the kind of content on which I typically work. We offer web writing in the company, but we don't really have an expertise in the type of content for which we employ WebpageFX. I was impressed with the level of education they've provided along the way. The amount of time that our account manager has spent with me explaining various approaches and the pros and cons for each one, including cost, has made me a far better informed customer.
I was taken with their use of Basecamp as a project management and tracking system. When working with companies via the web, a client won't know what they doing for most of the time. WebpageFX has the system set up in such a way as to allow us to log in to the system at any time and see what various members of their team are working on, what milestones they've set up, which ones were met, what had been done during a particular day, and what they would be doing the next day.
I liked the system so much that I adopted it for my own company. We have the same kind of issue, in the sense that clients send us projects that may take many months, so they can get very nervous about it. At no charge, WebpageFX gave me advice on setting up the system for my own company, which was beyond the call of duty for them.
What distinguishes WebpageFX from other providers?
One of the things that attracted me to WebpageFX was the fact that they were willing to analyze my needs before actually talking about a campaign. They also steered me away from higher-priced products, when they thought that a lower-priced one would please me more in the short term and educated me greatly about the industry without charging me.
Is there anything WebpageFX could have improved or done differently?
The proof is in the pudding, so we're still waiting for clients. We have gotten a few new ones and WebpageFX have increased our traffic, but this is only valuable to me if we receive paying customers as a result. I can't really complain, given that I'm seeing the kinds of results that are expected for our current progress. In six months, I may be able to give a better answer. For now, I cannot complain. WebpageFX is quick to respond, and their pricing is reasonable.
A number of people advised me that a $1,000 setup fee for a pay-per-click campaign was on the higher end. I wondered about this but, looking at the amount of work and tweaking that came with that cost, I think they've more than earned their money.
RATINGS
-
Quality
5.0Service & Deliverables
"I can't think of anything that hasn't pleased me."
-
Schedule
4.5On time / deadlines
"I slowed things down more often than they did. I've never found myself frustrated about their team not meeting a deadline...a couple of occasions in which a milestone was pushed to another day...But I never thought that they were just procrastinating."
-
Cost
5.0Value / within estimates
"In each case, the cost was what I expected it to be. What WebpageFX gave me for that was always more than what I expected."
-
Willing to Refer
5.0NPS
"I've already referred them to four or five different companies.