You are here

Logistics, Survey

Free Shipping or $2.99? Even Small Differences in Delivery Costs Matter to Consumers

December 03, 2019

Clutch found that online shoppers’ interest in a product dramatically decreases even with small increases in shipping cost. Businesses should consider offering free shipping to meet customers’ shipping cost expectations. They also can try building shipping costs into their products’ prices.

There’s a $10 hat you have been looking at online for some time now. It’s cheap and fashionable. You decide to take the plunge and put it in your online shopping cart, eager to check out. The final price pops up on screen: $12.99 after shipping.

You waver. Suddenly, the hat is less appealing when it’s more than $10. The $2.99 shipping cost decreases your interest in the hat.

New analysis from Clutch confirms that the appeal of free shipping may often be less about actual cost savings than customers’ unwillingness to pay extra fees. The extra $2.99 creates a mental barrier to purchase because the customer expected a $10 item.

We surveyed more than 500 online shoppers to learn what they expect to pay for shipping when purchasing different items online.

Even Small Shipping Costs Pose Challenges for Businesses

Our data points to key challenges businesses experience with shipping costs. We found that:

  • Small differences in shipping cost can lead to a large decrease in ordering from online shoppers: More than three-quarters (77%) of online shoppers say they are very likely to order an item they’re considering if the shipping cost is free, compared to only 43% who say the same for an item with $2.99 shipping.
  • Online shoppers expect free shipping almost equally for both small items, such as clothing, and large items, such as furniture. Thirty-two percent (32%) of online shoppers expect free shipping for small items, and 30% expect it for large items.
  • A similar number of Amazon Prime members and non-members expect free shipping for both small items (34% versus 28%, respectively) and large items (32% versus 27%). Amazon popularized the free shipping trend, but the expectation of free shipping is not limited to Amazon’s customers.

Solution: Build Shipping Costs Into Products’ Prices 

Based on the data, businesses should strongly consider offering free shipping if they don’t already.

Worried about the cost of free shipping? Businesses can try building shipping costs into their products’ prices.

Small Increases in Shipping Costs Decrease Customer Interest Drastically

Businesses may think they can please customers and still earn money by keeping shipping costs cheap but not free. Our data shows that even small increases in shipping costs decrease customers’ interest in a product, though.

Thirty-four percent (34%) more online shoppers say they’re “very likely” to order an item they’re considering if the shipping cost is free versus only $2.99.

Broken down, 77% of online shoppers say they’re very likely to order an item they’re considering if the shipping cost is free. Only 43% say the same when the shipping cost is $2.99. 

That means you could lose more than one-third of customers due to a $2.99 difference in price.

How Many Consumers Are Very Likely to Order an Item Online Per Shipping Cost?

The likelihood of ordering an item goes down further as shipping costs increase. Twenty-one percent (21%) of online shoppers say they are very interested in the product with a $5.99 shipping cost and only 13% of online shoppers say the same if the shipping cost is $8.99.

Consumers Expect Free Shipping for Items Both Large and Small

The desire for free shipping applies to both sweaters and sofas. 

A similar number of online shoppers expect free shipping for small items (32%) and large items (30%) alike.

Similar numbers of online shoppers expect free shipping for both small and large items.

Free shipping for a book or shirt seems easy to offer. When a business needs to ship a sofa or a television, though, it can feel harder to justify free shipping. 

Free Shipping Expectations Are Not Exclusive to Amazon Prime Members 

Online shoppers expect free shipping, even if they aren't ordering on Amazon.

Amazon first experimented with offering free shipping for certain orders in 2000. Since then, both the media and experts point to Amazon’s long-time push for free shipping as the reason why it’s popular among e-commerce consumers. Amazon’s size allows it to set standards for the entire industry; the e-commerce giant made $232.89 billion in product sales in 2018.

Amazon invests large amounts of money in its shipping and fulfillment, and these costs now equal a full quarter of its topline revenue.

We found that free shipping is not longer only popular among only Amazon’s customers. A similar number of Amazon Prime members and non-Amazon Prime members expect free shipping when they order an item online. 

A little more than one-third (34%) of Amazon Prime members expect free shipping for small items such as clothing. Twenty-eight percent (28%) of non-Prime members expect the same.

The data is similar for larger items such as furniture. Thirty-two percent (32%) of Amazon Prime members expect free shipping for large items, compared to 27% of non-Prime members.

How Many Amazon Prime Members Expect Free Shipping?

Free shipping is expected across the e-commerce industry.

The Solution? Include Shipping Costs in Your Products’ Prices

Our data shows the importance of offering free shipping to meet online shoppers’ expectations. Business owners, though, may complain that free shipping will decrease profits. There’s a solution: Build the cost of shipping into your products’ prices.

For example, instead of listing a hat for $10 with a $2.99 shipping price, price it at $12.99. While the product’s price is higher, customers also know exactly what they have to pay from the beginning, reducing lost conversions.

Including shipping costs into products' prices doesn't work for every business. For example, the strategy assumes the business is paying the same shipping cost for all customers. In reality, shipping costs differ greatly depending on how far you are sending the product. However, including shipping costs into products' prices works for many small business owners.

We spoke with several small business owners about how they meet customers' demands for free shipping. Many said they include shipping in the cost of some, if not all, of their products.

Lorenzo Ritson owns an online apparel shop and offers free shipping on every product.

“When a customer [adds] an item to their cart, moves into the checkout process, and sees the added cost of shipping, they will be significantly less likely to go through with the purchase decision,” Ritson said. “Offering free shipping has allowed us to convert more customers and increase sales.”

“Offering free shipping has allowed us to convert more customers and increase sales.”

Ritson still adds the cost of shipping into his products’ displayed prices. “This simple psychological trick decreases a customer’s cognitive dissonance and allows them to feel more confident going through the purchasing process,” Ritson said.

Stacy Case sells vintage items on her Etsy shop. She adds shipping costs into the price of the products she sells domestically. 

“I have always worked the shipping cost into my domestically sold items because when shoppers are browsing, they can see the full cost immediately,” Case said. “For me, there is nothing worse than finding a wonderful $6 item only to find out the shipping cost is outrageously high.”

Stacy Case Free Shipping Quote Card

Michael Anderson is a marketing specialist for GeoJango Maps, which sells push pin travel maps. 

Anderson says that people increasingly expect free shipping: “Retailers should be able to meet this need even if it means increasing prices or accepting a small reduction in profit.”

Small business owners can try adding shipping costs into their products’ prices. This may help them retain customers who would otherwise leave without purchasing after seeing shipping costs. 

Online Shoppers Want Free Shipping

Online shoppers don’t like shipping costs, even when they’re low.

Approximately one-third fewer online shoppers said they are very likely to purchase an item even if the shipping cost is even only $2.99 compared to free shipping.

Nearly one-third of online shoppers expect free shipping for both small and large items. There isn’t a large difference in free shipping expectations between Amazon Prime members and non-members.

Businesses should consider building the cost of shipping into products’ prices to decrease shoppers’ dislike of extra fees.

About the Survey

Clutch surveyed 528 people who ordered a package online in the past six months.

More than half of the respondents (66%) are female, and 34% are male.

The respondents' ages are as follows: 18 to 24 (16%), 25 to 34 (33%), 35 to 44 (26%), 45 to 54 (16%), and 55 to 64 (9%).

Respondents are all based in the U.S., either in the South (42%), Midwest (21%), Northeast (17%), or West (14%).