Are Negative Reviews Driving Your Customers Away?

Online reviews shape consumer purchasing decisions across a wide range of consumer segments. But how exactly are they using reviews to find, assess, and ultimately choose products and services? And how are businesses responding to the constantly evolving needs and expectations of today’s research-driven, social-proof-seeking consumers?

In this article, learn the impact of both positive and negative reviews, as well as how to start prioritizing your online review efforts. 

The Real Impact of Negative Reviews on Customer Decisions

According to the 2018 Online Reviews Survey by customer feedback software company ReviewTrackers, negative reviews and low ratings continue to drive away customers, with 94% saying they will avoid a business if it has been rated negatively online.

Plus, according to survey findings, a negative experience is more likely to prompt a review than a positive one, meaning dissatisfied customers often shape a disproportionate share of your online reputation.

This imbalance can have real consequences. A handful of unresolved complaints can outweigh dozens of neutral or positive experiences, especially when prospective buyers are researching a business for the first time.

Today’s consumers don’t just glance at star ratings. In fact, Clutch data shows that only 15% of consumers say they trust star ratings on their own. Instead, they actively read negative reviews to evaluate risk. They look for patterns in complaints, assess how businesses respond, and determine whether issues appear isolated or systemic.

In many cases, it’s not simply the presence of negative reviews that drives customers away, but how recent they are, how severe they seem, and whether the business has taken steps to address them.

For companies that fail to monitor and manage feedback, negative reviews can quickly erode trust, reduce click-through rates, and push high-intent buyers toward competitors.

The Best Star Rating to Aim For

While 85% of consumers look for validation beyond star ratings, nearly 72% say they would walk away from a product or service if the average rating drops below four stars, even if other trust signals are strong. This means that if your business doesn’t have a rating of at least 4 stars, you could be easily overlooked.

However, having a perfect 5-star rating isn’t necessarily the goal. Only 35% of consumers say they would fully trust a listing with only five-star reviews, while half say they would feel skeptical. That distrust is directly related to the rise of manipulated and AI-generated reviews. 

Maxime Siebinga, Marketing Manager at Flowium, shares, “We’ve seen brands with strong star ratings struggle when reviews feel generic, outdated, or inconsistent with current customer experiences. In those cases, shoppers tend to discount the rating entirely and rely more on recent, specific, and credible feedback.”

So, while you want to maintain a rating of 4 stars or above, it’s actually a good thing to not have only 5 stars. Ultimately, you want your online reviews to be largely positive, but having some honest customer feedback also presents a great opportunity to build trust. 

The Importance of Replying to Reviews

The growth of online reviews is strongly driven by customers’ genuine desire to engage with businesses.

Just as they did previously in traditional channels, such as surveys and support and service phone calls, customers want to be heard individually and addressed personally.

But businesses aren’t meeting their expectations.

According to ReviewTrackers’ survey, 53% of customers expect businesses to respond to their online reviews within a week. But 63% (nearly two-thirds) say a business has never responded to their review.

Managers must learn to address the gap between review response expectations and reality.

Responding to customer feedback makes a real, measurable difference: 45% say they’re more likely to visit a business that responds to negative reviews.

Taking the time to listen to customer feedback to respond to a negative review in a professional manner with a solution-focused approach has several benefits:

1. It could change the reviewer’s experience, leading them to possibly change their rating.
2. A potential customer on the fence might see your attentive response and decide to buy from you.

While bad reviews can negatively impact your business, they can also be an opportunity to grow and improve. 

How To Manage Negative Reviews 

Negative reviews are an unavoidable part of doing business. The goal isn’t to eliminate bad reviews entirely, but to manage them in a way that protects trust and reinforces credibility.

As review platforms continue to shape brand perception, businesses must take an active role in monitoring, responding to, and learning from customer feedback. Here’s a four-step process you can adopt within your organization to better handle your online reputation: 

1. Monitor Reviews Across Platforms

Consumers leave feedback in more places than ever before — from Google and Yelp to industry-specific review sites. Consistently tracking new reviews helps businesses identify issues early and respond before negative sentiment spreads.

Setting alerts or using reputation management tools can make this process more manageable, especially for multi-location or high-volume brands.

2. Respond to Negative Reviews Promptly

Knowing how to respond to a bad review is critical to maintaining customer trust.

A timely, professional response shows accountability and signals to prospective buyers that concerns are taken seriously. Even when feedback feels unfair, maintaining a calm, solution-oriented tone can prevent escalation and demonstrate brand integrity.

In some cases, thoughtful review responses can even encourage customers to update their rating after an issue has been resolved.

3. Look for Patterns in Negative Review Feedback

Individual complaints may be isolated, but recurring themes point to deeper operational challenges.

Common patterns businesses uncover include:

• Customer service gaps
• Fulfillment or delivery delays
• Product quality concerns
• Communication breakdowns

Treating negative reviews as a feedback loop rather than just a reputation threat allows companies to make improvements that reduce future complaints.

4. Encourage More Positive Customer Feedback

One of the most effective ways to manage negative reviews is to ensure they don’t dominate your review profile.

Actively inviting satisfied customers to share their experiences helps create a more balanced, trustworthy reputation. A steady flow of positive feedback can dilute the visibility and impact of occasional bad reviews.

Final Thoughts: Negative Reviews are Inevitable, But Manageable

Negative reviews are a natural part of doing business. In fact, a balanced mix of feedback often builds more trust than a perfect rating.

What matters most is how businesses manage them. Left unaddressed, bad reviews can erode credibility, impact star ratings, and drive potential customers toward competitors. But when handled thoughtfully, they create opportunities to demonstrate accountability, resolve issues, and strengthen customer relationships.

For businesses that lack the time or resources to consistently manage feedback, working with a reputation management (ORM) agency can help.

Reputation management partners support businesses by:

• Monitoring reviews across platforms
• Managing review responses
• Identifying recurring feedback trends
• Encouraging positive customer reviews
• Protecting brand perception and search visibility

With 96% of consumers reading reviews before making a purchase, proactive reputation management is essential to maintaining trust and long-term growth.

About the Author

Max Schleicher Head of Content, ReviewTrackers

Max Schleicher is the head of content at ReviewTrackers, where he enjoys culling data from online reviews to write about customer behavior and sentiment.

See full profile