Web Optimization, Dev & Design for Machinery Manufacturer
- Search Engine Optimization
- $10,000 to $49,999
- Jan. 2019 - Ongoing
- Quality
- 5.0
- Schedule
- 5.0
- Cost
- 4.0
- Willing to Refer
- 5.0
“It seems that WebFX has people that love doing this type of work, and it shows in the quality and the diligence.”
- Other industries
- Lancaster, Pennsylvania
- 51-200 Employees
- Phone Interview
- Verified
WebFX came onboard to revamp an agricultural machinery manufacturer’s website. Working with a partner contractor, they designed, developed, and optimized the site. They provide ongoing SEO services.
Organized and trustworthy, WebFX is committed to continuous improvement, which manifests in ever-improving web traffic and search rankings. They facilitate a seamless process, and the impressive results create value for cost. Internal stakeholders appreciate having a responsive point of contact.
A Clutch analyst personally interviewed this client over the phone. Below is an edited transcript.
BACKGROUND
Introduce your business and what you do there.
Pequea is an agriculture or farming machinery manufacturer. I’m the communications manager and am in charge of all technical communications, namely anything related to IT and outside marketing.
OPPORTUNITY / CHALLENGE
What challenge were you trying to address with WebFX?
Going back to the website two iterations before what we did with WebFX, that site had been set up by a local marketing firm, and it was good, but we hadn’t paid enough attention to it. We knew that our search engine results were very good; we were up there with multibillion-dollar companies on very generic searches. However, because we’d neglected the site, the CMS went extinct, and we needed to move on to something with more modern features so that we could update the site and make it look a bit nicer.
Rather than going with a tried and trusted firm, we went forward with the recommendation of someone who knew a programmer. We had the website designed, and it was good, but not great. I wasn’t very happy with the look of it, but it did what it was supposed to do, and it looked a bit more modern, cleaner, and more streamlined. After 6–8 months, I began getting questions from the CEO and the VP of sales as to why we weren’t showing up anymore in search results, which has been very strong with our previous website. I contacted the web developer and asked him to implement a few things, and he said he’d do what he could, but that he wasn’t an SEO expert.
He referred us to another company, and I contacted them. They reviewed our website and its backend, and they found out that there were no functional pieces for SEO to work properly. There were a few items there, but they couldn’t do 90% of what we needed. I’d just spent $15,000 on a website, and I’d have to go back now and seemingly redo it.
The ultimate goal was to get a website that had SEO capabilities, while also revamping the site so that we could continue to upgrade it and move forward in the future. Even though we had a nice-looking website, it just wasn’t set up for those things.
SOLUTION
What was the scope of their involvement?
We hired WebFX to develop our site in such a way that would give us SEO functionalities. This was a ground-up project; we tossed the old website and built a completely new one.
WebFX brought on a consultant that they work with. At first, I wasn’t too keen on that, because it felt disjointed; however, once the project got going, I saw how closely they worked together, and it was almost like going with one company. The consultant did the actual structure and design of the website, while WebFX was doing the SEO portion of it.
What is the team composition?
A salesperson from WebFX walked us through the sign-on process. Once we signed all of the contracts, they introduced us to someone else. We’ve only dealt with her and the president of the contracted company, so we’ve had just two key contact people. It’s easy to deal with just one person, rather than them referring us to other people.
We’ve had one key contact person for each portion of the project. If it was design and programming, I’d talk to the president of the contracted company; for everything else, including some of the design work, I talk to our person from WebFX. Most of the time, she doesn’t have to go to someone else. She knows what is going on and can answer my questions. If she ever does need to get back to me, she does so in a timely manner.
How did you come to work with WebFX?
Rather than picking some random person that would immediately tell us that the site needed to be redone, we started interviewing different web developers and web marketing companies. We shortlisted a couple, but WebFX ultimately had the best presentation. The detail in which they were suggesting to execute the SEO project was just far more intensive than any of the other companies that we talked to.
Anyone in a technical field — myself included, as I’ve been in IT for 19–20 years — tends to talk over others’ heads because they understand the technology. When some of these companies came in and gave us their pitch, they were talking even over my head in terms of catchphrases and terms. Although I was grasping some of the ideas via concept and contextual clues, ultimately, WebFX came in, laid out a presentation, and explained to us the technology and the different methodologies they wanted to use in order to build our ranking up. They explained how they were going to get there. Their presentation was really detailed and very easy to understand.
I didn’t have to do the legwork or paperwork in order to write up a proposal for administration and explain to them what was happening; WebFX did all of that for me, and all I had to do was pass around their proposal and allow people to read through it. Our admin team had very few questions about what WebFX was proposing, whereas with the other candidates, there were just too many technical terms. WebFX was the only company to come in and explain in layman’s terms what they were going to do. They were more expensive than every single other SEO company we interviewed, but what they were offering seemed to be worth more than what they were charging. They would be giving us a service at a higher level than all of the other providers, and that’s what we wanted.
We’re a small manufacturer playing in a huge pool of billion-dollar companies. We’re nowhere near that, and the only way we can compete on the internet is by having very good SEO and a good website. We needed to make a decision with that in mind, and we chose WebFX based on the proposal they gave us, but also on their previous work. We looked at whom they’d worked with and what the customer feedback was. Time and time again through that process, WebFX came out on top, beating everyone else. Their overall company image as the best SEO company in the area and maybe even in the Northeast really pushed us to go in that direction. After interviewing everybody, we decided to go with WebFX for our website and SEO project.
How much have you invested with them?
My company has spent $25,000–$50,000.
What is the status of this engagement?
The process of interviewing a team started in November 2018. We began working with WebFX in January 2019, and it’s an ongoing engagement.
RESULTS & FEEDBACK
What evidence can you share that demonstrates the impact of the engagement?
We haven’t gotten February’s numbers yet, but the biggest month for us was January. It was the first month where we saw an SEO increase of 25%, and an overall web traffic increase of 35%. People are being brought to the correct pages for the products they’re looking for. As for rankings, we’re growing, but we’re still not where we used to be. As I’ve told our admin team, I’m a firm believer that SEO is not an overnight thing. It’s the long game, and we have to just buckle down and ride it out, to let it naturally get to where it used to be. I’m very confident that it will happen.
I cannot praise the team at WebFX enough, especially our main contact. She sends me emails once or twice a week, including everything I need to know about what’s going on with our website and search ranking. She reports on all of the work they put in over the previous week, what that’s going to do for us, and whether there are any calls-to-action for me, such as if I need to review any modifications of texts or descriptions.
They’re constantly improving. We’re a lean manufacturer, and our philosophy is continuous improvement. I believe that the team at WebFX has brought that same philosophy to our website. If something small needs to be changed, it will be changed, and I’m always aware of it. I can see the quality and care going into this SEO, and I can see that we’re slowly rising. That slow rise and the increase of traffic are exactly what we’re paying for, and I really doubt that we’d have been able to get to where we are now with any other company. I think that WebFX was definitely the right choice to go with. Initially, I was somewhat nervous about getting involved in a situation with an outside contractor, but ultimately, it’s been completely seamless and worked out fantastically.
How did WebFX perform from a project management standpoint?
First off, their MarketingCloudFX solution is pretty awesome. The dashboard view I get to look at is just amazing. I print that out and give it to almost everyone here so that they can see what’s going on. It’s always an exciting time of the month for us to get that and show it around. They can see tangible results as to what we’re paying for and where we are in the entire stream of the project.
Their Content Genius uses AI to write articles. It's pretty cool but also a little time-consuming to go through the articles and make them sound more like a robot is not writing them. I do see what they’re doing, trying to hit on those keywords. If there’s any criticism, it’s the amount of time it takes to approve and rewrite these SEO articles. It’s still pretty cool that they have AI get in there and get close to where we need to be.
What did you find most impressive about them?
I appreciate the diligence. I don’t know if it’s WebFX as a whole, but the person representing them as a company is doing it well. They’re not just doing the work to get it done and to get the paycheck. It seems that WebFX has people that love doing this type of work, and it shows in the quality and the diligence.
I never feel like I’m bothering our contact when I call; in fact, she’s the one that initiates the conversation with me most of the time. She’ll call or email me, letting me know what’s going on and asking if I have any questions. I wish our company was as organized as WebFX is. They run a tight ship.
Are there any areas they could improve?
The only thing would be to have someone on board that could review the AI-suggested article changes. We’re a small company with a small marketing team, so the sales manager and I end up having to review all of those article changes, and it gets a little time-consuming. I’m working on a big project right now, and I have eight articles to review on MarketingCloudFX. If the articles were closer to perfect English, I wouldn’t have any critiques, but I have to go through them and reword a lot of it. If they had a person there reviewing them before they hit our pending slot, it would just make things go a lot quicker for us. That’s the only minor thing I could say about them, and it’s really not that big of a deal.
Do you have any advice for future clients of theirs?
A few other businesses have asked me for a recommendation, and I’ve referred WebFX. They were very easy to deal with on the sales part, and they find out what the client needs. We just saw our search results disappear, and we needed them to go back. WebFX came in and looked at what they could do for us.
What also helped in that process was allowing WebFX backend access to our website. That would be the one thing I’d recommend to a company. They’re not going to do anything malicious, and they’re professionals, so companies should let them see the backends of their websites. WebFX will know exactly what they need to do at that point to get the client off the ground. It’ll probably wind up saving the client money, so they don’t have to redo the process after signing on with them. They’re a trustworthy company, and clients should trust them from the onset and give them access to the backend, to get the analytics they need and make recommendations based on that.
RATINGS
-
Quality
5.0Service & Deliverables
-
Schedule
5.0On time / deadlines
-
Cost
4.0Value / within estimates
"They’re pretty pricey."
-
Willing to Refer
5.0NPS