Web Dev for Online Educational Company
- Web Development
- $10,000 to $49,999
- Apr. 2019 - May 2020
- Quality
- 4.0
- Schedule
- 4.0
- Cost
- 4.0
- Willing to Refer
- 4.0
"We came to a mutual agreement that satisfied all of our interests."
- Hospitality & leisure
- London, England
- 1-10 Employees
- Phone Interview
- Verified
Ralabs was hired to develop the backend of a corporate website.
While some parts of the project went smoothly, it was ultimately unsuccessful due to communication issues and misunderstandings. Since then, Ralabs and the client had a discussion and came to a mutual agreement. Both parties eventually decided to end the collaboration and did so respectfully. This review was originally 0.5 stars overall. It was updated by the client on July 10, 2020.
A Clutch analyst personally interviewed this client over the phone. Below is an edited transcript.
BACKGROUND
Introduce your business and what you do there.
I am a partner at a hospitality company that provides online education for hospitality. We are currently in the pre-launch stage.
OPPORTUNITY / CHALLENGE
What challenge were you trying to address with Ralabs?
We hired Ralabs to develop the backend for our corporate website, which is supposed to present our services.
SOLUTION
What was the scope of their involvement?
We had the frontend ready. We then did the initial design and programming, and we were supposed to adopt the backend. We worked on a time and material basis. When we received the invoice for the last sprint, the amount of time spent looked suspicious.
We asked them to check it and the developers said that it was fine. We then notified them that we would carry out an audit, and they confirmed and asked for a few days to prepare some comments.
After accepting their request, they asked for two more days every week for two months. Ralabs then told us that they wouldn’t provide access to the code to carry out the audit. They wanted us to make the payment first and then they would give us access to code to audit it.
Because of this, we lost our booking with the auditing company and we couldn’t explain to our partners and investors why our development company kept asking for an extension on a weekly basis, and Ralabs couldn’t explain it either.
We then carried out the audit with multiple auditing companies using time logs and the CMS, and it showed that the time was increased on average by 3–4 times for the last sprint. We also evaluated the whole project and came to the conclusion that 6–8 times more time was spent on development than necessary.
We did extensive research and talked to companies worldwide, asking them for their estimates. None of them could come close to explaining how we ended up spending that much time on this project.
What is the team composition?
Our main point of contact was Roman (CTO & Co-Founder) and we worked with 3–4 developers. Throughout the process, we were in touch with Roman and he was very nice and easy to talk to. However, we had a different experience with Andrew (CEO) who was unwilling to listen to us or negotiate.
We tried to go through friendly negotiation stages and even engaged mediators who we covered financially. During the 2-week timeframe we had allocated for negotiations, the CEO couldn’t find time to talk to us although he knew the project was on hold and we needed to solve it asap as we were losing time and money.
How did you come to work with Ralabs?
Our design partner, who we are very happy with, had experience working with Ralabs and recommended them. So, we thought that it would be easy for us to work with them too.
How much have you invested with them?
We paid $20,000. We didn’t cover the last sprints because we wanted to check the work.
What is the status of this engagement?
We worked with them from April 2019–May 2020. We told them we would be doing the audit in February 2020 and it was in April 2020 that we asked them to provide an explanation for why they kept playing for time and avoiding the audit.
We tried to be patient with them, believing that they would eventually give us access but, in May 2020, they said they wouldn’t do that.
RESULTS & FEEDBACK
Describe the impact this engagement has had on your business.
We will have to redo the whole project as the quality was low. We were supposed to have the project done by March 2020, but now it’s on hold. Additionally, we don’t have a website because everything is in the hands of Ralabs. Due to all of this, our relationship with our partners and investors has worsened.
We lost money, time, and our relationship with investors because of Ralabs. Our company has also experienced financial losses not only because of the standstill when we still have to pay salaries and cannot operate, but also because we paid for auditing services and for mediators to carry out friendly negotiations that didn’t end up happening because the team couldn’t find a time to talk to us.
After doing research and estimations, we discovered that we can redo what we have now with dozens of other companies within 3–4 weeks. Overall, we’re in a very bad position because of this. We trusted the recommendation that we got and we didn’t do many checks while we were hiring them.
How did Ralabs perform from a project management standpoint?
The project managers on our side had to spend more time on the project because Ralabs’ project managers had missed certain information or had forgotten to transfer it to IT. Most of the bugs that needed to be corrected had to be repeated 3–5 times.
Everything was perfectly fine up until we requested to carry out the audit. The team wasn’t able to meet deadlines. When we were adopting the backend to the new design, it took them three times longer than originally planned.
Is there anything that the vendor did well or that you would consider a strength?
The CTO did his best to negotiate, but we understood that he didn’t have a say in this situation.
In what specific areas can they improve?
I would suggest that they don’t treat customers like this, cheat, or play for time in the manner that we experienced. Ralabs knew that they put us in a bad position when they did this. If they know that they’ve done something wrong, they should just be honest about it, talk to their clients, try to understand their position, and not avoid it.
Do you have any advice for potential customers?
Be careful and understand that you won't be able to check the work provided. The whole experience ended up being a nightmare from a business point of view.
UPDATED REVIEW
This review was updated by the client on July 10, 2020. The original star ratings were: Overall - 0.5, Quality - 2, Schedule - 1, Cost - 0.5, NPS - 0.5. New content is below:
SOLUTION
What was the scope of their involvement?
We had two scopes of work with the developer - both involved backend work. The first sprint went fine and according to the schedule with a fixed price approach. For the second one, we were supposed to adopt the previously developed backend to an updated design working on a time and material basis.
Our expectations were that the second sprint would go as efficiently as the first one went and at some point, we relaxed the control over the situation. This eventually led to misunderstandings and different views on how the work should be done and how long it should take.
The whole situation generated confusion between our companies and we decided to find another developing company to proceed with.
What is the team dynamic?
Our main point of contact was Roman (CTO & Co-Founder) and we worked with 3–4 developers on an ongoing basis. Throughout the process, we were in touch with Roman and he was very nice and easy to talk to.
Although, initially, we found it hard to come to an agreement with Andrew (CEO) we want to acknowledge that he eventually heard us and put a lot of effort into communication.
We resumed our negotiations efficiently, and we are pleased to confirm that Ralabs showed respect to our circumstances, and they agreed to satisfy our requirements and compensate for our expenses.
How much have you invested with them?
We paid $16,000
What is the status of this engagement?
We began working with them in April 2019 and the disagreements arose in April 2020. In June 2020, we terminated the collaboration in a friendly manner without any claims from either side.
RESULTS & FEEDBACK
How did your relationship with the vendor evolve?
We have gone through different stages in our relationship. As in any collaboration, we had periods when everything moved smoothly and periods when complexities or misalignments in understanding, views, or approaches between our team arose.
While we decided it was best for both teams to stop the engagement, we are pleased with the fact that the termination went smoothly and based on the future interests of both our project and Ralabs'.
How did Ralabs address the challenges that arose?
Despite misunderstandings and lack of efficiency in the negotiations at the outset, in the end, Ralabs' management team demonstrated a willingness to collaborate and to take into consideration the difficulties and long-term interests of the client. Eventually, we came to a mutual agreement that satisfied all of our interests.
Describe the impact this engagement has had on your business.
We decided to redo the project as the speed and approach appeared to be unsuitable for our needs.
As a result of the incomprehension and lack of efficient communication with Ralabs, we have gone through a difficult and burdensome period of keeping the project on hold and having complicated relations with investors and partners.
However, we want to commend Ralabs' efforts in resolving the generated complexity between our companies. We have seen the transformation in attitude and approach from their management.
I am sure that both of our teams have emerged from this crisis being wiser and more attentive. Eventually, Ralabs navigated this situation with a focus on long-term relations and the client’s interests.
How was project management handled?
The project managers on our side had to spend more time on the project because occasionally information was missed or not transferred in a timely manner to respective managers. Even though we terminated the partnership, Ralabs consented to fix the bugs.
Is there anything that the vendor did well or that you would consider a strength?
Roman, the CTO did his best to negotiate throughout the collaboration. The CEO demonstrated an ability to adapt, pay attention, and stand up for the long-term interests of both his company and his client.
In what specific areas can they improve?
We suggest that Ralabs pay attention to customer dissatisfaction at earlier stages and be more transparent in their communication. This is a good lesson for both of us and I'm sure this situation will not be repeated with new clients. We are glad to have ended this collaboration with mutual respect and understanding.
What advice do you have for clients with similar needs to yours?
Discuss everything with more attention, and clear out confusion or unexplained issues right away. Additionally, be clear and insistent in explaining your position and arising complications if you have any.
RATINGS
-
Quality
4.0Service & Deliverables
-
Schedule
4.0On time / deadlines
-
Cost
4.0Value / within estimates
-
Willing to Refer
4.0NPS